Skip to main content

Order Online today and save 10%

Order Online today and save 10%

Passion Lives Here

Pizzeria Commack

Bring Friends & Family at Milano’s Pizzeria & Restaurant!

Welcome to our website where you can order online, inquire about catering for all occasions and browse our collection of delicious pasta, pizza, salads, heros and more. Our location has been in Commack for over 30 years proudly serving the community formally known as Paradise Pizza. We are located in the Commack Commons shopping center diagonally from the Bike Cave. Our customers enjoy a variety of pizza with healthy options like gluten-free, cauliflower crust, delicious salads with nuts, berries and assorted cheeses. 

About Us
Best pizza in Commack

We Care About Offering Great Food For All Customers


We pride ourselves on the excellent service we provide to our customers and our amazing prices.


Each pizza is prepared with the freshest ingredients and our staff is friendly when serving you.


We have gluten free options available on our menu upon request.

Order Online Today and save 10%

Read what our regulars are saying...


5 Star Review
A very “slept on” pizzeria. some of the best regular slices in town. staff takes the time to get to know everyone and it really gives the place an old style feel. 10/10

Scott P.

5 Star Review
Always the BEST pizza! This family-run pizzeria/restaurant is delicious, warm, welcoming, and the owner takes a good ribbing about being a Jet fan!

Corinne H.

5 Star Review
If you want authentic homemade Italian Pizza & food nearby, this is the spot? Huge helpings ! From a comfortable setting to personal customer service, you can't go wrong. Family owned. Cooks Grace & Joe make such a wide range of delicious authentic meals, no one will go hungry. I love this place. I keep coming back for more !

Our great pricing and services get even better when you include our coupons.

Click here to discover what specials we proudly offer and take advantage of our exclusive deals while they last!

Order now the best pizza in Commack!

Get coupons

Come and Visit Us!

211 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725

Business Hours:

Monday to Thursday 10:00 am - 9:00 pm
Friday & Saturday 10:00 am - 10:00 pm
Sunday 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

Get Directions


Subscribe to our weekly email list for new menu item releases, events, discounts, and more! 

Thank you for sending your message.